Why Migrate SQL Server to PostgreSQL？
In the construction of modern data platforms, an increasing number of organizations are considering migrating their existing SQL Server environments to PostgreSQL. This trend is not coincidental but driven by multiple factors including database technology advancements, enterprise cost control, and evolving business requirements. The core reasons behind this shift primarily encompass the following four aspects:
- Licensing and Cost Advantages: Microsoft SQL Server is a commercial product with relatively high licensing costs, whereas PostgreSQL is an open-source, free database with an active community.
- Cross-Platform and Flexible Deployment: PostgreSQL supports Linux/macOS/Windows, making it suitable for cloud-based and multi-platform deployments. While SQL Server has gained Linux support in recent years, it remains heavily reliant on the Microsoft ecosystem.
- Technical Features and Extensibility: PostgreSQL supports JSON, complex custom types, and rich extension mechanisms; it can better accommodate modern data architectures in certain scenarios.
- Data Platform Integration Requirements: For instance, when organizations aim to unify their database platform, reduce multi-vendor technology stacks, or plan future data warehouse/big data integration, PostgreSQL becomes an ideal choice.
Therefore, when decision-makers search for “how to migrate data from SQL Server to PostgreSQL” or “how to migrate SQL Server database to PostgreSQL,” it reflects a practical need for the advantages mentioned above. Next, we will explore how to choose SQL Server to PostgreSQL tools.
How to Choose an SQL Server to PostgreSQL Migration Tool
The migration process from SQL Server to PostgreSQL is complex, and the choice of tools directly determines the efficiency, security, and final outcome of the migration. Since different business scenarios have vastly different migration requirements, there is no “one-size-fits-all” solution. Therefore, when selecting tools, it is essential to assess them based on your specific needs, focusing on the following core criteria:
- Downtime window requirements: If business downtime is acceptable, manual or batch tools may suffice. For mission-critical operations requiring continuous uptime, tools with real-time synchronization capabilities are recommended.
- Data Volume and Complexity: For large datasets with complex structures (including triggers, stored procedures, foreign keys, indexes), prioritize comprehensive, highly automated tools.
- Incremental Change Capability: Does the migration require ongoing synchronization of source system changes? If so, select tools supporting Change Data Capture (CDC) mechanisms.
- Budget and Resources: Open-source tools incur no licensing fees but may require more manual intervention; commercial tools are more expensive but offer support and automation.
- Support for Heterogeneous Environments: Does the migration involve multi-tenant, multi-source, or specialized data platforms? The tool should support heterogeneous database migration.
- Monitoring and Validation Mechanisms: Does the migration process support logging, validation checks, error retries, and status monitoring? These features enhance migration security.
Migrating SQL Server to PostgreSQL – Manual Methods
When migrating from SQL Server to PostgreSQL, manual migration offers flexibility and control, making it a crucial choice for small-to-medium-scale migrations or scenarios requiring deep customization. While this approach demands more manual configuration, it enables precise control over critical steps like data conversion and schema mapping, avoiding the “black box” risks associated with automated tools. Among these, SSIS (SQL Server Integration Services) leverages the Microsoft ecosystem to provide visual ETL design, while SQLserver2pgsql offers lightweight scripting to meet basic migration needs.
Option 1. Migrate SQL Server to PostgreSQL with Sqlserver2pgsql
Sqlserver2pgsql is an open-source Perl script tool specifically designed to migrate SQL Server databases to PostgreSQL. It supports converting SQL Server schemas to PostgreSQL schemas and generates data migration scripts usable in Pentaho Kettle jobs.
- Tool and Environment Deployment
Download the sqlserver2pgsql script (supports Perl or Python versions) from GitHub. Ensure the corresponding runtime environment (e.g., Perl interpreter) is installed locally. Meanwhile, configure SQL Server’s sqlcmd tool and PostgreSQL’s psql tool to execute the generated scripts.
- Configure Migration Parameters
Edit the tool configuration file (e.g., sqlserver2pgsql.conf). Fill in the connection information for the SQL Server source database (address, username, database name) and the PostgreSQL target database (address, port, database name). Specify the tables to migrate or exclude unnecessary objects (e.g., system tables).
- Generate Migration Scripts
Run the sqlserver2pgsql script. The tool will automatically connect to SQL Server, parse information such as table structures, indexes, and constraints, and generate two core SQL scripts: schema.sql (table structure creation script) and data.sql (data insertion script).
- Execute Scripts and Data Loading
Use the psql tool to connect to PostgreSQL. First, execute schema.sql to create the target table structure. Then, execute data.sql to import data. For large tables, split the script or use psql’s batch import parameters (e.g., –single-transaction) to ensure data consistency.
- Manual Adjustment and Validation
Due to the tool’s limited support for converting complex objects (e.g., stored procedures, triggers), manually rewrite the logic of these objects to adapt to PostgreSQL syntax. After migration, compare the data volume and key data between the source and target databases using psql commands or visual tools to confirm the migration results.
Option 2. Migrate SQL Server to PostgreSQL with SSIS
SQL Server Integration Services (SSIS) is the core data integration and ETL management component of Microsoft SQL Server. It not only performs data extraction, transformation, and loading tasks but also enables complex data flow automation through scripting and process control. During SQL Server to PostgreSQL migration, SSIS serves as a bridge to efficiently migrate database table structures or data in bulk to the PostgreSQL environment. It also supports scheduled or real-time synchronization, ensuring data remains continuously updated throughout the migration process.
- Environment and Component Preparation
Install Visual Studio and the SQL Server Data Tools (SSDT) component. Ensure that the ODBC or OLE DB driver for PostgreSQL (e.g., Npgsql) is installed to enable SSIS to connect to the target database.
- Create SSIS Project and Data Flow Task
Create a new SSIS project and add a “Data Flow Task” to the Control Flow. In the Data Flow design interface, configure the “OLE DB Source” (to connect to SQL Server and select the tables to migrate or write queries) and the “ODBC Destination” (to connect to PostgreSQL and specify the target tables) respectively.
- Data Transformation and Mapping Configuration
Based on data type differences between SQL Server and PostgreSQL (e.g., VARCHAR vs. TEXT, DATETIME vs. TIMESTAMP), add a “Data Conversion” component to the data flow. Manually map fields, adjust data types, and handle special constraints such as primary keys and auto-increment columns.
- Execute Migration and Monitoring
Debug and execute the SSIS package, and monitor the migration progress through the “Execution Results” window. For large tables, split tasks or set up incremental migration logic to avoid excessive pressure from a single migration.
- Post-Migration Validation
Compare the table structure, row count, and key field values between the source and target databases to verify data integrity. Check the conversion results of objects like triggers and stored procedures (SSIS requires manual handling of logical migration for such objects).
|
Features |
SQLserver2pgsql |
SSIS |
|
Cost |
✅ |
✅ |
|
Ease of operation |
⚠ |
✅ |
|
Automated architecture conversion |
✅ |
⚠ |
|
Support for incremental synchronization |
❌ |
⚠ |
|
Enterprise-grade capabilities |
❌ |
⚠ |
As you can see, while these two tools can meet the needs of small-to-medium scale or simple scenarios, neither offers real-time synchronization or enterprise-grade data consistency guarantees. When business requirements demand non-disruptive migration or high-security compliance, a more advanced solution is necessary.
Enterprise-Grade Real-Time Migration Solution[Hot]
i2Stream is a data stream replication management software provided by Info2Soft, supporting real-time data transfer between heterogeneous databases, including big data platforms and message queues. It synchronizes data from various database sources to target environments in real time, encompassing but not limited to database migration scenarios.
- Comprehensive Compatibility: Supports diverse database versions and operating systems, enabling cross – version and cross – platform migrations. Handles different character sets, field types, and database objects, ensuring seamless data transfer.
- Flexible Synchronization: Offers one – click and incremental sync options, with support for full and incremental sync via database backups, meeting varied business needs.
- Precise Replication: Allows fine – grained replication at instance, database, user, table, and field levels, along with mapping between different entities.
- Strong Data Assurance: Enables online data comparison, automatic discrepancy repair, and has features like logical deletion blocking and sequence calibration to safeguard data quality.
- High – performance Migration: Facilitates multi – job concurrency with one program, and supports dynamic multi – threaded sync for efficient full and incremental migrations.
- Easy Management and Monitoring: Provide a user – friendly graphical interface for integrated management. Comes with various alerts to keep the migration process in check.
You needn’t worry about i2Stream’s usage and migration adaptation — Our experienced technical support team proactively delves into the specifics of your IT environment (including the deployment architecture of the source SQL Server, configuration requirements for the target PostgreSQL, and business continuity needs). We conduct targeted environment compatibility testing, pre-migration process rehearsals, and critical feature validation. Any issues encountered during testing are promptly resolved. Our professional services eliminate tool usage barriers, ensuring your migration progresses smoothly.
Conclusion
This article provides a comprehensive guide for migrating from SQL Server to PostgreSQL. It first outlines the migration rationale for PostgreSQL in terms of cost, cross-platform deployment, technical features, and data integration. It then clarifies that tool selection must consider core criteria such as downtime windows and data volume. Subsequently, it details the applicable scenarios and characteristics of two manual migration methods: the open-source Sqlserver2pgsql script and Microsoft’s SSIS component.
If you face enterprise-level requirements such as non-disruptive migration and high security compliance, consider i2Stream. With its comprehensive compatibility, precise replication, and robust data protection, i2Stream can ensure your migration process runs efficiently and smoothly, safeguarding your database migration journey.